SB on Game of Thrones: Blog Entry Fourteen
– Episodes 5.7, 5.8, 5.9, & 5.10 (For 4/26/16)
New Connections in this Set of
Episodes
In
this week’s set of assigned Game of
Thrones episodes, many major characters formed new (and/or rekindled old)
relationships with other major characters.
These new (and renewed) connections that were covered in this set of
episodes might see further development in (and have a significant impact on the
major plot points of) season six.
One
old relationship that was rekindled in this set of episodes was the sibling
relationship between Sansa and Theon (or “Reek,” if you prefer Theon’s new name). The interactions between Sansa and Theon that
took place in episodes 5.7 and 5.8 were particularly fascinating because these
scenes depicted the initiation of a major change in Theon’s character.
This
change in Theon’s character could not be observed or confirmed by viewers until
episode 5.9 when Theon threw Myranda from the castle (to her death) in order to
escape with Sansa. However, it is
asserted that the scenes of dialogue between Sansa and Theon in episodes 5.7
and 5.8 showed Sansa helping Theon rediscover his true identity and remember
his true name (namely, “Theon” rather than “Reek”).
One new
relationship that began and developed in this set of episodes was the political
relationship between Danaerys and Tyrion.
The Targaryans and the Lannisters are historical enemies but,
interestingly, Danaerys and Tyrion share certain political goals in
common. Also, even though Danaerys and
Tyrion are quite different characters, these are two of my favorite
characters. The above listed facts made the
scenes that covered this relationship to be particularly intriguing to me. Even though Danaerys flew away on her dragon
and left Tyrion in the coliseum in episode 5.9, I still predict (and hope) that
Danaerys and Tyrion will interact in future episodes of Game of Thrones.
Native American Indian History in
Game of Thrones
In
addition to new interpersonal relationships, this week’s set of episodes also
contained coverage of the development of new relationships between groups of
people. Consider the scenes in episode
5.8 that showed the negotiations where Jon Snow wanted to unite with the Wildlings in order to stand up to the White Walkers.
It
is clear that these negotiations (between Jon Snow and the Wildlings) have been
happening in other recent episodes (that were not from this week’s assigned
episodes). It is also clear that other
COMS 650 students have already made connections that are similar to the
connection that I am about to make in some of their previous blogs. However, I
made the observation that these scenes in episode 5.8 (that covered the
negotiations) reminded me of certain characters and episodes from Native
American Indian history.
As
discussed by Jake Page in In the Hands of
the Great Spirit: The 20,000-Year History
of American Indians, Tecumseh (a Shawnee) was one figure of historical significance
who was dedicated to unifying various American Indian tribes in order to stand
up to even greater hostile invasions. These
negotiations that took place in episode 5.8 shared commonalities with Tecumseh’s
situation: cultures that had previously
fought with one another attempted to put aside their differences and unite in
order to face a different kind of force that threatened the existence of their home
and culture.
According
to Jake Page, scholars have argued that some general regions of the
contemporary United States have more American Indian culture than other areas
because these areas (with more American Indian culture) are the areas where,
historically, different American Indian tribes united and displayed the most
resistance to hostile invasion. As
discussed in In the Hands of the Great
Spirit: The 20,000-Year History of
American Indians, Tecumseh (a supporter of the unification of American
Indian tribes) was killed in battle, but his vision of unification inspired
others long after his death.
Jon Snow
(a supporter of the unification of Game
of Thrones tribes) was brutally killed by the Nights Watch at the end of
episode 5.10. However, viewers can still
maintain hope that these groups might put aside their differences and unite in
order to stand up to the invading White Walkers.
Works
Cited
Page, Jake. In the Hands of the Great Spirit: The 20,000-Year History of American Indians. New York,
NY: Free Press, 2004. Print.
I see a couple things driving the Theon/Sansa relationship: 1.) can she see him as a broken man and forget that he was the murderer of people at Wintefell (even though he explains that Bran and Ricon are alive)? 2.) before being castrated, Theon was an incredible sexist pig. Can he now develop some sympathy for a battered woman? (I'm not persuaded that this is a brother/sister relationship.)
ReplyDeleteAbout Native Americans, I would say what drove Native American settlement in the post-Manifest Destiny era was whether the land was valuable. With all that rich farmland in Illinois, no way they would let them stay. Whereas in a cold, heavily forested area such as Northern Wisconsin, ok, we can let them stay, although we would rather pack them off to Oklahoma or Montana. By the way, that portrait of Tecumseh may or may not be him--no one's ever been able to verify it definitively.
I definitely see some potential depth in this relationship between Sansa and Theon. Only interesting component is that Sansa (who has typically been a week character that follows whims, emotions, or stronger personalities) IS the stronger personality in this relationship. It's giving her an opportunity to flex her growing assertiveness muscles. And she's doing so in a wiser way than she could have done before.
ReplyDeleteDavos might be that common-sense guy they need to push this vision of uniting to fight the White Walkers. He is a very knowledgeable guy and extremely likable, so he seems like the logical heir apparent to that hero role Jon fit so well.
ReplyDelete“or “Reek,” if you prefer Theon’s new name” This made me chuckle. I definitely think we have a lot to look forward to, in regards to Tyrion and Dany. Seriously great look at the comparison of the Wildlings to American Indians.
ReplyDelete“or “Reek,” if you prefer Theon’s new name” This made me chuckle. I definitely think we have a lot to look forward to, in regards to Tyrion and Dany. Seriously great look at the comparison of the Wildlings to American Indians.
ReplyDeleteI still think it's weird that Dany accepted Tyrion so readily, yet she cast Jorah aside after proven loyalty. I liked Dany a lot better my first time around watching the series, but this time around, much less so. I would rather see Tyrion council somebody else.
ReplyDelete